
When I started this blog, I bought cheaper toys first so I could figure out what I liked before spending more on the expensive ones. That’s still what I tell anyone who asks me where to start, with one big condition: cheap has to mean inexpensive, not unsafe. A $20 jelly vibrator that you throw out after a few months, or that leaves you irritated every time you use it, is not a bargain.
Fifty dollars is a very workable budget for a first toy, or for a spare one, as long as you know which materials and which kinds of toys stay affordable without cutting corners. One thing before I start: I’m in Canada, and most of the “under $50” lists you’ll find online are in US dollars. Once you convert and add shipping, a $45 USD toy is far from a $45 toy here. Always check which currency the shop is showing you before you fall in love with anything.
First, the non-negotiables
Body-safe means non-porous and free of the nasty stuff. The materials I trust are 100% silicone (not a “blend”), glass, ABS plastic, stainless steel, and some stone and properly sealed wood. Jelly, rubber, PVC, TPE or TPR, “cyberskin” and anything labelled “for novelty use only” are porous: they hold on to bacteria no matter how well you wash them, and some of them contain softeners you really don’t want in contact with your mucous membranes. If you want the long version, the material & safety section of my Useful links & guides page lists the guides I learned from.
Where $50 goes the furthest
Glass dildos
Glass is the easiest way to get a body-safe insertable on a small budget. Borosilicate glass, the same heat-resistant type used for kitchenware, is non-porous, rigid, easy to clean and compatible with every type of lube. You can warm it up or cool it down with water, and it never wears out if you take care of it. Many mass-produced glass dildos sit well under $50, and some of them are lovely, like the Icicles No5 that reminded me why I fell for glass in the first place.
What to look for: a thick, even piece with no air bubbles inside, no chips, no rough seams, and no painted decorations on the surface. Inspect it under good light before every use, and store it in a padded pouch so it can’t knock against your other toys.
ABS plastic vibrators
Hard plastic doesn’t sound glamorous, but ABS is non-porous and inexpensive to manufacture, which is why it’s behind most budget classic vibrators and bullets. A hard plastic slimline vibe won’t have a velvety finish, and its motor will often be buzzier than what you’d get at a higher price, but it’s safe and very easy to clean. The thing to watch for: some cheap vibrators have a soft “jelly” sleeve or tip glued over the plastic, and that part is the problem. Make sure the whole toy is plastic, or plastic and silicone.
Small silicone bullets and mini vibes
Silicone vibrators under $50 do exist, they’re just small. Bullets and mini vibes are where budget silicone is most common. Expect fewer settings and a weaker motor than a premium bullet, and if you plan on using it often, a rechargeable one will cost less in the long run than one that eats AAA batteries. Buy from a brand that is open about what its toys are made of. If a listing only says “premium silicone”, with no brand, no material information and a suspiciously low price, I would pass.
Stainless steel and small plugs
Steel looks expensive, but small stainless steel plugs and simple steel dildos often fit under $50. Metal is non-porous, can be boiled, works with any lube, and has a nice weight to it. Look for a seller who states the grade of steel, a smooth polish with no rough welds, and, for anal use, a flared base that is clearly wider than the rest of the toy.
Lube counts too
A good water-based lubricant is one of the best things you can buy under $50, and it will make an inexpensive toy feel much nicer. Look for a short ingredient list, and if glycerin or parabens irritate you, skip formulas that contain them. I compared two of my favourite water-based lubes in my Sutil Luxe & Rich review (in French).
What you give up at this price
Being honest about what you’re not getting saves a lot of disappointment:
- Power: budget vibrators are mostly buzzy rather than rumbly. If you need strong, deep vibrations, saving a bit longer for a wand may be a better use of your money. I compared the two main types in Wand Vibrators Compared: Corded vs Rechargeable.
- Noise: cheaper motors tend to be louder and higher pitched.
- Finish: visible seams, mould lines, glossy silicone that collects lint.
- Warranty: many budget brands offer little or none.
None of these make a toy unsafe. They’re trade-offs, and knowing about them before you buy means you can choose which ones you’re okay with.
Red flags in a cheap listing
- No material listed at all, or vague words like “silicone blend”, “TPR silicone”, “sil-a-gel” or “jelly”.
- “Phthalate-free” presented as proof of safety. A porous material without phthalates is still porous.
- “For novelty use only” hidden in the fine print.
- A strong chemical smell when you open the box, or a surface that feels oily or sticky.
- Marketplace listings with stock photos and no real brand behind them. As I said on my Where to buy page, buying toys from those sites is a gamble with mislabelled materials and counterfeits.
If you want help decoding the rest of a product page, from decibels to sizes, I wrote a separate guide on reading toy specs.
Where to look
Shops that only stock body-safe products save you most of the detective work. On my Where to buy page, I listed the retailers I like in Canada and the US, with notes on which ones also sell porous products so you know when to read descriptions carefully. Some of them, like Peepshow Toys, even have a section dedicated to vibrators under $50. Sales are your friend as well: several shops run 20% or 25% off promotions on a regular basis, so a toy that is slightly over your budget today may well fall under it in a few weeks.
My budget picks, by type
- First insertable: a thick, well-made glass dildo.
- First vibrator: a rechargeable silicone bullet from a brand that lists its materials, or an all-ABS classic vibe.
- Anal beginner: a small steel or glass plug with a proper flared base.
- Always: a decent water-based lube, because it makes everything better.
Spending less doesn’t mean settling for something that could hurt you. Pick the right material, accept the small compromises, and your $50 toy can stay in your toy box for years.
